Last refreshed

Semenyo vs Caicedo

Head-to-head FPL comparison for 2025/26. Stats, fixtures, and transfer trends.

Caicedo currently has the edge on form (1.5 vs 1.3), while Semenyo leads on total points (178 vs 100). At £8.2m vs £5.7m, Caicedo is the budget-friendly choice.

Semenyo
Semenyo
MCI MCI · Midfielder
VS
Caicedo
Caicedo
CHE CHE · Midfielder

Stats Comparison

Semenyo Stat Caicedo
£8.2m Price £5.7m
178 Total Points 100
1.3 Form 1.5
5.7 Pts/Game 3.6
55.5% Ownership 7.5%
15 Goals 3
6 Assists 1
10.25 xG 1.39
2.39 xA 2.07
224.0 ICT Index 93.5
17 Bonus 10
2770 Minutes 2352
-56,867 Net Transfers -3,033

Fixture Difficulty (Next 6 GWs)

PlayerClubGW33GW35GW36GW37GW38Avg
SemenyoMCIMCI BUR (A) EVE (A) BRE (H) BOU (A) AVL (H) 2.8
CaicedoCHECHE BHA (A) NFO (H) LIV (A) TOT (H) SUN (A) 3.0

Verdict

Semenyo gets the edge. While both are strong midfielder options, Semenyo currently offers the better combination of form, fixtures, and value.

  • Form: Caicedo is the in-form pick at 1.5 vs 1.3. Neither is on fire right now.
  • Fixtures: Near-identical difficulty ahead (2.8 vs 3.0). Fixtures won't separate them.
  • Value: Semenyo returns 21.7 points per £1m vs Caicedo's 17.5. Semenyo is the better value pick, and the £2.5m price gap frees budget for upgrades elsewhere.
  • Goal threat: Semenyo has more goal involvements (21 vs 4 G+A). Expected stats also back Semenyo on xG.
  • Transfer trend: Caicedo has stronger transfer momentum (-3,033 net vs -56,867). The crowd is moving but no price change is imminent.
  • Ownership: Semenyo is the template pick at 55.5% — safe but offers limited rank gains. Caicedo (7.5%) is the differential with more upside.

Related

Semenyo Profile Caicedo Profile Should I Buy Semenyo? Should I Buy Caicedo? Best Midfielders Season Hub

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is better in FPL, Semenyo or Caicedo?
Based on current form, Caicedo has the edge with a form rating of 1.5. However, Semenyo has 178 total points vs Caicedo's 100.
Should I pick Semenyo or Caicedo for FPL?
Semenyo costs £8.2m with 55.5% ownership, while Caicedo costs £5.7m with 7.5% ownership. Consider upcoming fixtures and your budget.
Semenyo vs Caicedo: who has better fixtures?
Check the fixture difficulty comparison below. The player with more green (easy) fixtures in the next 6 gameweeks has a schedule advantage.

Get Personalized Transfer Advice

Our AI analyzes your squad to recommend the best pick between these two players.

Analyze My Team